Thursday, August 19, 2010

Left Parties On Civil Nuclear Liability Bill

On Standing Committee Report on Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Bill

The Left parties had, at the very outset, opposed the draft legislation on Civil Nuclear Liability when it was sought to be introduced in Parliament. A reading of the Bill made it clear that the purpose of the legislation is directed more towards protecting the US nuclear reactor suppliers from claims of liability and compensation and less about providing effective and speedy compensation to the people affected by a nuclear accident. The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Science and Technology has now submitted its report in which it has made certain recommendations. The members of the Left Parties in the Standing Committee have registered their dissent to the report and recommendations. The Left Parties wish to explain to the people the objectionable features that would still exist in the legislation if the recommendations of the Standing Committee are accepted.

Protecting Foreign Suppliers
Clause 17 of the Bill currently reads as follows:
17. The operator of a nuclear installation shall have a right of recourse where —
(a) such right is expressly provided for in a contract in writing;
(b) the nuclear incident has resulted from the wilful act or gross negligence on
the part of the supplier of the material, equipment or services, or of his employee;
(c) the nuclear incident has resulted from the act of commission or omission of
a person done with the intent to cause nuclear damage.
The Standing Committee has recommended that Clause 17 should now be amended as follows (changes in bold):
17. The operator of a nuclear installation shall have a right of recourse where —
(a) such right is expressly provided for in a contract in writing; and
(b) the nuclear incident has resulted as a consequence of latent or patent defect, supply of sub-standard material, defective equipment or services or from the gross negligence on the part of the supplier of the material, equipment or services.
(c) the nuclear incident has resulted from the act of commission or omission of
a person done with the intent to cause nuclear damage.

By adding “and” in sub-clause 17 (a), the right of the operator to claim damages from the supplier of nuclear equipment and material (right of recourse) has now been made entirely contingent on whether such right is explicitly provided in the private contract between the operator and supplier. In the likely scenario of the foreign suppliers not agreeing to provide for right of recourse in the contract, they cannot be held liable for any nuclear damage, even if they have supplied defective equipment. What is more dubious is that this significant weakening of Clause 17 has been done under the guise of strengthening the right of recourse against the foreign suppliers.

The US administration and the American nuclear industry lobby have objected to sub-clause 17 (b). They are not prepared to accept the right of recourse for the Indian operator vis-à-vis American suppliers. The Standing Committee recommendation is fully in line with the demand of the American lobbies. This amendment linking 17 (a) and 17 (b) will make it worse than what is there in the original Bill.

Liability Cap Unacceptable
The recommendation to enhance the operator’s liability cap from Rs. 500 crore to Rs. 1500 crore is hardly significant, since total liability for each nuclear incident remains capped at 300 million SDRs (Rs. 2122.40 crore or $ 455 million) as per Clause 6 (1). This amount is less than even the Bhopal settlement of $ 470 million, which has been acknowledged as grossly inadequate by the Government itself.

It is noteworthy that none of the international nuclear liability conventions set any cap on total liability, but only set a floor. Countries like South Korea and Sweden have set operator’s liability at 300 million SDRs, not total liability. The operator’s liability in the US is $ 11.9 billion. Countries like Japan, Russia and Germany do not have any cap on total liability. In contrast, the Indian bill seeks to cap total liability to 300 million SDRs, displaying scant regard for the lives and security of the Indian people.

Further Objections
The Standing Committee report has failed to take on board several more objections to the Bill, especially regarding the extant provisions protecting the operator and suppliers from facing litigation and the ambiguities regarding nuclear accidents in defence installations and the jurisdiction of the AERB. It has also made an objectionable suggestion to create a liability fund to reduce government liability by levying additional charges on electricity.

The recommendations of the Standing Committee does not alter the fact that the intent behind the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Bill, as well as its provisions, are meant to facilitate India’s joining the Convention on Supplementary Compensation (CSC), which was explicitly committed by the UPA-I Government to the US in 2008, during the nuclear deal negotiations. Other than the US, no other country having a substantial number of nuclear plants have signed or ratified the CSC. None of India’s neighbours who could be affected by a trans-boundary impact of a nuclear accident are signatories to CSC and its funds cannot be used for augmenting trans-border compensation for settlements. India gains nothing from joining the CSC.

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

DYFI protest against delay in issue of Ration Cards

15,000 people came together under the flag of Democratic Youth Federation of India, in Thiruppur to protest against the inordinate delay in the issue of ration cards in the district and the irregularities in the distribution of essential commodities through fair price shops on the 16th of August.The demonstration was held in front of the Kumaran Statue to express their displeasure over the issues.

The Government authorities and DMK ministers were proclaiming that ration cards will be issued in 45 days to 2 months time. But the actual fact is that the people are not at all getting the cards in the stipulated time. Mostly people living in dwellings and slums are the worst affected. 

It is in this context that DYFI, Thiruppur district conference took place in August 1 and 2. The conference took stock of the situation and decided to launch militant struggle against this delay in issue of cards. It was on the basis of this decision that August 16 protest was organised. DYFI activists across the district went to each and every house and gave the message of the protest to the people and asked them to participate in the movement. 

DYFI district secretary R. Vadivel said that the delay in the issue of cards had been depriving thousands of economically poor from availing the subsidised food grains.  DYFI State joint secretary A Bala, District president Adv. Y Anandan etc led the movement.The protest which started in morning lasted till 5 pm in the evening. Similar protest rallies were held in Avinashi, Kankayam and Udhumalai in the district. Various district  and local leaders of DYFI led the movement.

CPIM, TNUEF activists of Gudiyatham gets bail

CPIM, TNUEF leaders including Gudiyatham MLA G Latha and TNUEF state secretary P Sampath, who were were arrested for holding a demonstration against demolition of houses of Dalits and Muslims in Veloor district were released in bail on 17th August.

The struggle was launched for the resettlement Dalits and Muslims who were forcibly evicted by anti socials of real estate mafia with the support of the ruling DMK and government officials on the 12th of August. The anti socials demolished the dwelling places of 39 families of dalits and muslims who were living there for the past 100 years. The already settled dalit and muslim people were forcilble evicted by the real estate mafia with the help of police.The District Administration earlier assured to take action on the evictors and arrange for resettlement but become a mute spectator.In this context the TNUEF and CPIM launched a massive picketing struggle in front of Gudiyatham Taluk office demanding resettlement of evicted dalits and muslims on 12th August.Later the police arrested the leaders and 59 other activists including 16 women and remanded. They were charged with false cases.
Protest demonstration were held across the state against the highhandedness of the police against the cadres.

Tamil version of EMS Namboothiripad's "History of Freedom Struggle" released


The Tamil translation of the book titled ‘A History of Indian Freedom Struggle' authored by late Communist leader E.M.S. Namboodiripad was released at a function organised by the Thiruchi district committee of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).

Veteran CPI (M) leader and the party's central committee member R. Umanath released the Tamil version ‘Indhiya Viduthalai Poratta Varalaru' translated by K. Elakuvan, and handed over the first copy to the Communist Party of India State control commission member R. Karuppaiah.

The CPI (M) central committee member and MP T.K. Rangarajan, CPI State council member M. Selvaraj, Tamil Nadu State Progressive Writers Association State president Arunan, CPI(M) district secretary S. Sridhar and others were present.

In his address, Mr. Rangarajan said the book by E.M.S. Namboodiripad contained bare facts and truth about the freedom struggle without any bias and clearly spelt out the role played by Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. The Communist movement had fought against repressive measures, he said.

Hailing E.M.S. Namboodiripad as a great leader, Mr. Rangarajan recalled the special qualities of the late leader.

He called upon party functionaries to read the book's Tamil version. It was essential to mobilise people and drum up support to take on challenges in the era of liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation, he said.

(Courtesy : The Hindu)

CPIM campaign against price rise from August 22-29

CPIM Tamil Nadu state committee which convened its meeting on 16th and 17th decided to conduct a vociferous campaign against the price rise of essential commodities and the anti-people policies followed by DMK government in the state and UPA government in the centre. The meeting was chaired by Central committee member Comrade U Vasuki. PB member K Varadarajan, CC member N Varadarajan, State Secretary G Ramakrishnan participated in the meeting.

It has been decided to conduct a week long campaign from August 22 to 29th. Committee observed that the price rise of essential commodities has came down heavily on the common man and the people are struggling hard to keep the both ends meet. And the recent hike of petroleum products has added fuel to hardship.

The committee decided to go for a door to door campaign, where by 50 lakh families in 3000 branches will be reached out. As part of this campaign 3000 padayatras will be carried out across the state. From August 30 to September 5 big mass meetings will be held at Chennai, Salem, Neyveli, Madurai, Kovilpatti and Thiruchi. In these mass meetings leaders including Com. S Ramachandran Pillai, Com. Sitharam Yechury, Com. Brinda Karat will be participating.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

DYFI Protests against Bad Roads in Mangalore

Fed up with the despicable condition of roads in Panjimogaru area, the members of Democratic Youth Federation of India (DYFI) alleged that the administration has neglected its duties towards the citizens by not undertaking repair works.

Staging an agitation in front of the Mangalore City Corporation (MCC) building here on Monday August 16, DYFI district president Muneer Katipalla informed that commuting in Panjimogaru has become a nightmare as the road is full of potholes and there is not even a footpath for pedestrians.

Though a few of the roads have been repaired, the work done was inferior and already they are full of potholes, he said, and added that despite increasing tax some time ago, the administration has not paid attention to the needs of the residents of the area.

He also added that the drains are blocked and damaged, further worsening the condition of the road. But the administration has been turning a blind eye to the citizens' misery and is instead busy concreting the main roads of the city, he alleged.

DYFI district secretary Dayananda Shetty and others were present at the protest.

(Courtesy : Mangalorean.com)

All India Convention on Education



Massive March to Parliament planned on December 2

An All-India Convention on Education was held in New Delhi on 13th August 2010. Organizations of Students, Teachers, University Employees, Youth, People’s Science Movements and Parents participated in the convention. Ritabrata Banerjee All India General Secretary of SFI moved the draft resolution on behalf of all the organizations at the beginning of the Convention. This Convention was addressed by Comrade Sitaram Yechury, Comrade D Raja, Comrade Abani Roy and Dr Barun Mukherjee along with leaders off all organizations which were participating. The Higher Education Minister of West Bengal Sudarshan Roy Chowdhury, Professor Prabhat Patnaik, Vice Chairman Kerala Planning Board and Professor Soumen Chattopadhyay from JNU also addressed the Convention.  The Convention resolved to strengthen the struggle against the education policies of the UPA II Government and make it more board based.
The draft resolution which was adopted in the Convention resolved to launch a National Forum in Defense of Education and hold a massive rally on December 2 in Delhi.

The Convention adopted the following resolution:
This National Convention of Students, Teachers, University Employees, Parents, Youth and Science Movements expresses its resolve to fight against the anti-people policies of UPA II Government in the field of education. These policies are aimed at pushing commercialization, centralisation and privatization of the education sector in the country. Such policies will undermine the goal of expansion, excellence and equity in education which can only be achieved through increased public spending based on a democratic education policy. This convention upholds the following demands:

·   Allocate 6% of GDP for Education as committed in the CMP of the UPA-1 Government.   
·    Include pre-primary to senior Secondary education under the purview of the Right to Education. Central Government should bear all the expenditure for implementing the Right to Education. Increase the number of schools along with strong social monitoring mechanism involving local stake holders.
·    Recruit quality teachers on a permanent basis. Remove the freeze on appointments and cuts in teaching and non-teaching positions.
·  Oppose handing over of public educational institutions’ infrastructure and management to the private sector in the name of Public Private Partnerships.
·  Reject fee hike. Fully subsidize students from economically backward and disadvantaged backgrounds.
·   Enact a central legislation to bring all private self-financing institutions under strict social control.     
·   Implement constitutionally mandated SC/ST/OBC reservations in all educational institutions.
·   Fight all attempts to undermine the democratic control of the Parliament, State Assemblies and statutory structures of Universities and colleges (including through instruments like NCHER). Fight against centralization of education.
·   Oppose FDI in Education.
·   Scrap the FEI Bill and suitably amend the other recently introduced bills.
·   Scrap private universities and deemed university status to private institutions.
·  Use Information Technology for Distance Education to provide universal lifelong quality education. Do not commercialize distance education.
·  Undertake Assessment for improvement not Accreditation or Funding. Evolve a democratic and transparent mechanism for Assessment.
·   Uphold democratic rights in the sphere of education. Hold elections for Students’ Unions, Teaching and Non-Teaching Associations. Provide elected representation in all decision making bodies.

This Convention resolves to launch NATIONAL FORUM IN DEFENCE OF EDUCATION. This Convention gives a clarion call to hold a massive rally on December 2, 2010 involving all stakeholders like students, teachers, non-teaching employees and officers of schools, colleges & universities, youth, parents, people’s science movement in order to force the Central Government to accept the aforesaid demands and related issues. To make this rally a grand success such convention at the level of states, districts and institutions should be organized.

Stop Centralisation, Privatisation and Commercialisation
Save and Strengthen Public Education


SFI, AISF, AISB, PSU, DYFI, AIYF, RYF, AIYL, STFI, AIFUCTO, DTF, AIUEC, AIPSN, BGVS, AIPA

"SHE"- SFI magazine for women released


"SHE", a new generation magazine brought out by SFI Kerala state women subcommitte was released by award winning actress and dancer Lakshmi Gopalaswamy at a function in Thiruvananthapuram. First copy was received by Calicut University Union former chairperson Com P Jiji. SFI state committee member Seethal David presided over the function. SFI All India General Secretary Rithabratha Banerjee, SFI State Secretary P Biju spoke on the occassion. The magazine will be brought out once in 3 months. Other than stories, poems, articles the magazine will be carrying Campus memories, Interviews with leading stars in every field, notes on sports and trendz. SFI Women Subcommittee converner Dhanya Vijayan is the  chief Editior of the magazine. SFI Kerala state committee is already bringing out a monthly named Student which is having wide circulation.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Ban entry of foreign universities: SFI Tamil Nadu State Conference

Foreign universities must not be allowed to establish their facilities in India, said State president of Students Federation of India (SFI) Regis Kumar.

A resolution to this effect was passed at the SFI's 22nd State conference.

The SFI also demanded that the government must implement equitable education so that wards of all poor people get benefited.

From 37 matriculation schools in 1977, the number had increased to 4,500 in the State.

The government must ensure 1:30 student-teacher ratio, make mother tongue as medium of instruction mandatory in schools and functioning of private schools must be streamlined, particularly regarding fee structure.

Planning Commission member from West Bengal Ramachandran inaugurated the delegate session of the conference. He said that India was one of the most illiterate countries in the world. Hence, the SFI must work toward eradicating illiteracy.A casteless society must also be created, Mr. Ramachandran said.

Saturday, August 14, 2010

SFI TamilNadu State Conference begins in Nagercoil


22nd SFI Tamil Nadu State conference began in the southern most district, where the 3 seas converge, Nagercoil on 13th August with huge student rally. The student rally was flagged off by SFI all India President Comrade P K Biju. Thousands of students from various parts of Tamil Nadu participated in the rally. The rally was lead by Com. G Selva (All india Joint Secretary, Com Kanakaraj, Com Rejiskumar, Com Jasmin Vinoja. The rally was acommpanied by various arts forms. 22 students carrying White flag indicating the 22nd conference marched in the front row. Thuderous slogans were made by the participants against the commercialisation of education sector. They pledged to fight against the commercialisation of education done both by the central and state governments. Activists of DYFI, AIDWA, CITU gave fraternal greetings to the rallyists.  

Later the meeting was inaugurated by CPIM central Commitee member and Kerala State Education minister Com. M A Baby. CITU TN state Secretary Com. A Soundarrajan, Com P K Biju MP, Com G Selva spoke on the occassion. Organising Committee Chairman Com. AV Bellarmin, Com Leema Rose MLA, Com John Joseph MLA were present at the meeting venue. SFI district presdent Com Sathya gave the vote of thanks. The Conference will continue on 14th and 15th of August. The delegate session of the conference will be inaugurated on 14th August by leading educationalist K Ramachandran.